Create your own awesome maps

Even on the go

with our free apps for iPhone, iPad and Android

Get Started

Already have an account?
Log In

Deliberative polls talk, Azi Lev-On by Mind Map: Deliberative polls talk, Azi Lev-On
0.0 stars - reviews range from 0 to 5

Deliberative polls talk, Azi Lev-On

Unlike Internet examples such as

Etsy Town hall meetings

Second Life meetings

&c

deliberative democracy

definition in Gutman & Thompson, p7

goverment form in which free citizens or their representatives deliberate on options for decisions which are binding

why

instrumerntal

legitimizes

encourage different perspectives aimed at common good

community

personal empowerment

distinctions

Deliberation vs. Aggregation

Deliberation vs. Discourse

Deliberation vs. Participation

Implementation:

representative or participatory

sample representing the population

or all inclusive

Fishkin

Fishkin & Luskin, 1999

<see flyer>

process, choose sample of the population, contact them, send materials presenting, questions/decisions, arguments pro/con each, event day, opening talk, bottom up, different groupd, with moderators, moderators are skilled in making sure all opinions are heard & preventing discussion perils, such as, Cascading reputation, ..., See Infotopia book, lunch, which contributes a lot to the education/state-of-mind effects, groups discuss, groups present summaries, voting

3 themes

participation, sample of full population taking part in decision making

experts, injecting knowledge & ideas

deliberation

findings

Significant changes in, knowledge, sophistication, consolidation of solutions

examples, US, EU, China, standard tool for perfecture level decision making, Hungary & Bulgary, Decision regarding Roma (Gypsies), Australia

see, http://cdd.stanford.edu/

Israel

During the summer there will be an experiment in Israel

Online deliberation polls

Were tested in the US since 9 years ago

Q&A

taking representative sample of the population helps

address the problem of scale

ensuring heterogenic & representative groups

goal

improve decision making

not fitting questions in which people have dogmatic unchangable views

condition for deliberative polls is the commitment of the decision makers to accept the decision

New alternatives raised during the deliberation are not taken into account in the vote

unlike gov discussions (parliament, committees), deliberative polls tend to change people's opinions

there is a thorough & transparent process of reviewing the initial materials aren't biased